Clinique cream shaper eyeliner or Revlon colorstay eyeliner?

which eyeliner stays in place the longest and DONT smudge?


for information i just wear eyeliner on the eyelid... i dont wear eyeliner at the bottom eye... from these 2 brands, which would you recommend me?Clinique cream shaper eyeliner or Revlon colorstay eyeliner?
clinique is generally a better brand.





but the word ';cream'; sounds like it will smudge





so i'd say the colorstayClinique cream shaper eyeliner or Revlon colorstay eyeliner?
I'd say the Revlon Colorstay would be the best